By the Mayab Media Team
More than a million referrals a week. That's how fast Reddit's search traffic was dropping on average through October, according to CEO Steve Huffman on the company's October 29 earnings call. He added that the slide sped up late in the third quarter.
If your plan for 2026 included "get our brand mentioned on Reddit so we show up in Google," read that twice.
What Reddit actually said
We went through the call transcript so you don't have to. The business itself is doing well: Revenue hit $895 million in Q3, a 53% jump on last year. The traffic picture is a different story.
Reddit counted roughly 130 million daily active uniques. Huffman warned that if October's trend holds, that figure could fall by a low double-digit percentage in Q4. Most of the damage hit logged-out web visitors. In plain terms, people who used to click a Reddit thread from a Google result.
He blamed AI Overviews and AI Mode for pushing results further down the page. On AI Mode he was blunt: it "does not drive traffic, not for us." He went on to say he doesn't think it sends much to anyone else either.
Then came the bigger news.
Reddit will start testing a logged-in-only experience in select markets outside the US this quarter. Huffman called it a test, but said plainly the company is going to make that transition. He also said Google is crawling Reddit "as hard as ever." What a login wall means for how threads show up in Google wasn't explained on the call. Nobody outside Reddit knows yet, and we wouldn't trust anyone who claims to.
One more line caught our eye. COO Jennifer Wong said Reddit is "pretty skeptical of GEO," the industry's term for trying to get brands into AI answers.
Why this matters even if you never post there
For the past couple of years, a lot of SEO advice treated Reddit as a back door into Google. Threads ranked for product questions and "best X near me" style queries, so the play was to get your name into those threads.
That play is weaker now. Not dead. Weaker.
Three things have shifted. Fewer searchers click through to Reddit. Reddit's own CEO says AI Mode isn't sending visits. And a login wall could make threads less useful to the casual searcher, even if Google keeps indexing them.
Our view? Reddit still matters. Real customers still argue about vendors there, and AI tools still read it. But treat it as a reputation channel, not a traffic channel.
Selling B2B software? Same logic. Your buyers may still read Reddit before a demo call. Fewer of them will land there from Google.
Here's a quick way to see where you stand. Say you run a dental clinic with two locations, and a local thread about dentists for nervous patients has been sending you visitors. In GA4, open Reports, then Acquisition, then Traffic acquisition, and filter session source for "reddit." If that line showed 40 sessions a month in spring and 15 now, you have your answer. (Hypothetical numbers, but the check takes two minutes.)
Where we'd move the effort
Start with your own data. Pull Reddit referral sessions for the last 12 months and put them next to Google organic. If Reddit was never more than a rounding error for you, close the tab and move on.
Skip the "Reddit seeding" services that plant recommendations. Wong said Reddit is well protected against manipulation, and a fake thread that gets spotted does more damage than no thread at all.
Take the questions people ask about your industry on Reddit and answer them properly on your own site.
Those pages are yours. Nobody else gets to put a login wall in front of them.
If someone on your team already answers questions there under a real, disclosed account, keep going. Logged-in users are the audience Reddit is betting on; Huffman said logged-in and app users together drive over 80% of its monetization. Those are also the people most likely to remember your name.
And watch the test markets. If Reddit threads start slipping in search results there, rank-tracking tools will show it well before anything changes in the US.
Reddit is still a good place to earn trust. It's a poor place to rent your Google traffic.
Want us to check how this affects your business? Book a free audit.
